Share
You hired a VA with real optimism. Three weeks in, you're doing most of the work yourself, fixing half their output, and wondering if you made a mistake. Before you chalk it up to "VAs don't work" — which is what most owners conclude — let's diagnose what's actually happening.
In the Jarvis client base, 85% of "bad VA" situations that come to us are fixable without replacing the VA. The problems are almost never about the VA's intelligence or work ethic. They're about the setup. Here's how to figure out which situation you're in.
My Virtual Assistant Is Not Working Out: Diagnose Before You Act
There are four categories of "not working out." Each has a different fix.
Category 1 — Skill gap: The VA doesn't know how to do the task. Fix: better training, clearer examples, or a different role assignment.
Category 2 — System gap: The VA doesn't have clear instructions, SOPs, or tools. Fix: documentation and process work. This is the most common category and the most fixable.
Category 3 — Communication gap: Feedback is delayed, expectations are unclear, or the check-in system isn't working. Fix: management changes. See the management framework.
Category 4 — Fit gap: The VA is genuinely not suited to the tasks or your working style, regardless of system quality. Fix: replacement. This is rarer than you think.
The 3-Question Diagnostic
Before doing anything, ask yourself three questions about each task that's going wrong:
- Did I give them a clear definition of done for this task?
- Did I give them an example of what good output looks like?
- Did I give feedback within 24 hours of seeing a problem?
If the answer to any of these is no, fix that first. Don't have a performance conversation with a VA about failures that were caused by your system. It's not fair to them, and it won't produce the result you want.
One real estate agent we work with was ready to fire his VA after 3 weeks. He'd never sent an example of a good client follow-up email. He'd never told his VA what "timely" meant. His definition of done was "reply to clients" — which his VA was doing. What he actually wanted was something different from what he'd described. When we went through the diagnostic, all three answers were no. Fixed the system, gave examples, gave feedback. Two weeks later, problem solved.
Having the Direct Conversation
If you've fixed the system and the problem persists, you need a direct conversation. Most owners avoid this because they're worried about being harsh or creating conflict with a remote worker. That avoidance costs weeks of bad output.
Here's the Jarvis framework for a VA performance conversation:
- State the specific issue: "The last four client emails you sent didn't include the follow-up date I asked for."
- State the impact: "Clients are following up with me instead of you, which is what we were trying to prevent."
- State what you need: "Every client email needs a next-steps line with a specific date. Can you do that consistently?"
- Listen to their response. If there's a system barrier you didn't know about, fix it. If they commit to the change, track it for two weeks.
A VA who responds with "yes, understood, I'll fix it" and then doesn't — that's a replacement conversation. A VA who explains what was confusing and changes their approach — that's a management win.
Having VA Problems? Talk to Us First
Jarvis clients can request a free 15-min consultation if a placement isn't working. We'll diagnose before we recommend a replacement — because often we can fix it without one.
Talk to the Jarvis Team
The 2-Week Improvement Plan
After the performance conversation, set a 2-week improvement plan with specific, measurable targets. Don't say "improve your email quality." Say "every client email needs a next-steps line, sent within 4 hours of the request, with no typos. I'll review every email this week and give same-day feedback."
Track daily. If day 3 is already better than week 1 — you're in the right direction. If day 7 looks the same as day 1 — the VA isn't capable of or willing to make the change, and you have your answer.
The plan also protects you. If you end up needing to replace this VA, you've given a fair, documented opportunity for improvement. That matters for your own accountability as a manager, and it matters for the VA service — they need to know whether the failure was performance or fit before they match you with someone new.
When to Actually Cut Your Losses
Some situations don't need a diagnostic. Replace immediately if: the VA is dishonest about task completion (marking things done that aren't), they stop communicating without explanation for more than 24 hours, they make unauthorized changes to live systems, or they give repeated false progress updates.
These aren't performance issues — they're character issues. No management system fixes them. If you're with Jarvis, email the team and request a replacement. We start the search same day.
See how the Jarvis replacement guarantee works and what the typical turnaround time looks like for finding a better-fit replacement.
After the Replacement: Setting the New VA Up Differently
The biggest mistake after a failed VA: hiring the replacement with the same broken onboarding. Before the new VA starts, document the system gaps that caused the first failure. Write the SOPs. Set up the task tracker. Build the example library. Give the replacement the setup the first VA deserved from day one.
Most people who say "I've tried three VAs and none of them work" have never fixed the underlying system. The symptom is the VA. The disease is the setup. The 7-day onboarding framework is the fastest way to get the next VA performing right from the start.