BELAY is one of the most recognized virtual assistant services in the US — and one of the most expensive. If you're evaluating options, here's what you're looking at on the pricing side before diving into alternatives:

  • BELAY part-time (15 hrs/week): ~$1,750/month
  • BELAY full-time (40 hrs/week): ~$3,100+/month
  • Contract minimum: typically 3 months
  • VA location: US-based (which drives the cost)

For some businesses, a US-based executive assistant is worth the premium. For others — especially those doing $10K–$100K/month who need operational support, not a C-suite EA — there are better options at half the cost. Here's an honest comparison.

1. Jarvis — Best for Full-Time Operational Support at Offshore Pricing

Price: ~$1,600/month (full-time, 40 hrs/week)
VA location: Philippines
Best for: Service businesses, agencies, coaches, e-commerce founders doing $10K–$100K/month

Jarvis is the most direct replacement for BELAY if you need full-time support but not a US-based EA. The core difference: Jarvis VAs are pre-trained on business operations tools (CRM, inbox management, scheduling, reporting) and AI-certified before placement. They also build automations on top of delegated tasks — so repetitive work gets eliminated entirely over time, not just transferred.

How Jarvis compares to BELAY:

Feature BELAY Jarvis
Price (full-time) ~$3,100/month ~$1,600/month
VA location US-based Philippines
Vetting process Internal screening 67-point live assessment
AI automation No Yes — VAs build workflows
Onboarding time 1–2 weeks 5 business days
Money-back guarantee No 14-day guarantee
Industry focus Executive assistants Business operations ($10K+/mo)

Who should choose Jarvis over BELAY: Business owners who need a full-time operational VA — not a traditional executive assistant — and want AI automation built alongside delegation. If your primary need is inbox management, CRM, scheduling, and reporting (not executive diary management for a Fortune 500 exec), Jarvis delivers more at lower cost.

2. Boldly — Best Premium US Alternative

Price: ~$2,000–$3,500/month (full-time)
VA location: US and Europe
Best for: Executives who need a high-touch, experienced EA

Boldly is BELAY's closest competitor in the premium US-based space. They focus on experienced executive assistants with 10+ years in their fields. Price is similar to BELAY; the main differentiator is Boldly's emphasis on long-term retention (they keep assistants employed as W-2 workers, reducing turnover).

Downside vs Jarvis: No AI automation capability. 2x the cost for full-time support. Best suited for C-suite executives needing high-touch EA work, not operational VAs for growing businesses.

3. Time Etc — Best for Part-Time Flexibility

Price: $360–$1,080/month (10–30 hrs/month)
VA location: US and UK
Best for: Business owners who need occasional help, not a dedicated VA

Time Etc operates on a pre-purchased hours model. You buy a block of hours per month, and tasks are handled from a pool of VAs. This is cost-effective for low-volume needs but lacks the continuity of a dedicated VA — every task may go to a different person with no institutional knowledge of your business.

Downside vs Jarvis: No dedicated VA, no AI automation, and the shared model breaks down at volume. If you need more than 10–15 hours/month, a dedicated model like Jarvis delivers better consistency and lower per-hour cost.

4. Zirtual — Best for US-Based Dedicated Support

Price: $549–$1,699/month (part-time tiers)
VA location: US-based
Best for: Small business owners who specifically need US-based support

Zirtual offers dedicated US-based VAs at a lower price point than BELAY. Their VAs are college-educated and assigned to you specifically. They work well for administrative tasks: calendar management, email, research, data entry.

Downside vs Jarvis: No AI automation. Limited hours even at the highest tier (40 hrs/month = 10 hrs/week). If you need genuine full-time support, Zirtual's tiers cap out before you get there.

Free Delegation Audit — 15 Minutes
Not sure which tasks to hand off first? In 15 minutes, a Jarvis strategist will map your week, identify your highest-leverage delegation targets, and show you exactly what a trained VA can own from day one.

→ Book your free audit call

5. MyOutDesk — Best for Real Estate

Price: ~$1,988/month (full-time)
VA location: Philippines
Best for: Real estate agents and brokerages

MyOutDesk is a solid option if your business is real estate. They've built their VA training around real estate workflows: lead follow-up, CRM management (Follow Up Boss, LionDesk), showing coordination, and database mining. Outside of real estate, their differentiation is limited.

Downside vs Jarvis: Higher price than Jarvis for similar offshore VA quality. No AI automation layer. Not ideal for non-real estate businesses.

6. Magic — Best for On-Demand Task Work

Price: Usage-based, starting ~$10/task
VA location: Global
Best for: One-off tasks, not ongoing operational support

Magic is a task-based service — you send a request via text or app and someone handles it. There's no dedicated VA and no institutional memory of your business. It works for occasional, clearly scoped tasks but falls apart as a full operational support model.

7. Fancy Hands — Best for Micro-Tasks

Price: $18–$50/month (5–15 tasks)
VA location: US-based
Best for: Very low volume, simple tasks

Fancy Hands is for micro-tasks — making phone calls, scheduling appointments, basic research. Not appropriate for business owners who need an operational backbone. Included here for completeness, not as a serious BELAY alternative for scaling businesses.

How to Choose the Right BELAY Alternative for Your Business

The right alternative depends on your primary need:

  • You need a traditional C-suite executive assistant (US-based): Stay with BELAY or try Boldly.
  • You need full-time operational support at the lowest cost: Jarvis.
  • You need occasional help without a commitment: Time Etc or Zirtual (lower tiers).
  • You're in real estate and need industry-specific training: MyOutDesk.
  • You want AI automation built alongside your VA: Jarvis (only option that offers this).

For most business owners doing $10K–$100K/month who want to reduce their operational workload without paying US-salary rates, Jarvis is the most cost-effective full-time option with the strongest vetting process (67-point assessment) and the only AI automation layer included.

Not sure where to start? Download our free delegation checklist — the 12 tasks most founders hand off in week one. Get it when you book your free call.

Learn More About Jarvis

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best alternatives to BELAY for virtual assistants?

The top alternatives are Jarvis (~$1,600/month, full-time Filipino VA + AI automation), Boldly ($2,000–$3,500/month, US-based premium), Time Etc ($360–$1,080/month, part-time flexible), Zirtual ($549–$1,699/month, US-based dedicated), and MyOutDesk (~$1,988/month, real estate focused).

Why do people look for BELAY alternatives?

BELAY's pricing — $1,750/month for part-time and $3,100+/month for full-time — is among the highest in the VA services market. Businesses that need full-time operational support often find offshore VA services deliver comparable quality at 40–50% lower cost.

Is Jarvis a good alternative to BELAY?

Yes, for businesses that need full-time operational support rather than a traditional executive assistant. Jarvis offers pre-trained Filipino VAs at ~$1,600/month with AI automation capability — roughly half the cost of BELAY's full-time tier, with a 14-day money-back guarantee and 5-day onboarding.

Book a free 15-minute call with Jarvis — most clients are matched and onboarded within 5 business days.

Back to blog